A couple of weeks ago, I and a few other ASL experts compiled our QB rankings to create a consensus positional ranking. Since then, here are the changes I have made to my own quarterback rankings, which I have updated below: 

-- I flip-flopped Deshaun Watson and Matthew Stafford to 7 and 8, respectively. I wouldn't say I love Watson this year, especially at his astronomically high ADP in some leagues. But there is also a legitimate non-zero chance he finishes as the No. 1 player at his position. That upside is worth more than Stafford, who is a very fine fantasy quarterback but will not end up in the top five.

-- Another flip-flop with Andrew Luck and Jimmy Garoppolo at 11 and 13, respectively. Luck has not put up boffo numbers during the preseason. But that's not really important. What is important is that his passes have looked generally sharp and been delivered with some good speed. I think he's more rusty than recovering at this point, and I'm ready to move him back into QB1 range. Jimmy G, as I said in my consensus write-up on him, is probably going to alternate really good fantasy days with really bad ones this year.

-- I moved Patrick Mahomes up one spot in front of Matt Ryan. In that QB2 range, you're much better off going with Mahomes' upside. The kid has some pretty freakish ability. That's been on display this month.

-- Eli Manning is up a few spots to No. 19. Look, I know he's running on fumes, but the Giants' defense isn't great, and Eli has every type of offensive skill-position weapon available to him. At the very least, I had to move him past Blake Bortles. I don't know what I was thinking there. Apologies.

-- I bumped out Case Keenum for Andy Dalton. You're getting desperate in that range, but I do believe last year was a fluke for Keenum. I've been pretty down on the Denver offense as a whole this summer.

-- My top five didn't change. I thought hard about moving No. 6 Carson Wentz down with all of the "will he, won't he?" speculation over his Week 1 playing status. But I firmly believe he'll be out there as the starter in a couple of weeks, and I feel like there is a clear line of demarcation between him and the QBs beneath him.

IT'S HERE! Draft Analyzer can now sync to all fantasy leagues! Get Draft Analyzer to make yourself a champion!

More rankings: Consensus Top-50 RBs || Consensus Top-50 WRs

Rank Player Team
1 Aaron Rodgers GB
2 Russell Wilson SEA
3 Tom Brady NE
4 Cam Newton CAR
5 Drew Brees NO
6 Carson Wentz PHI
7 Deshaun Watson HOU
8 Matthew Stafford DET
9 Kirk Cousins MIN
10 Ben Roethlisberger PIT
11 Andrew Luck IND
12 Philip Rivers LAC
13 Jimmy Garoppolo SF
14 Marcus Mariota TEN
15 Jared Goff LAR
16 Alex Smith WAS
17 Patrick Mahomes KC
18 Matt Ryan ATL
19 Eli Manning NYG
20 Dak Prescott DAL
21 Derek Carr OAK
22 Mitch Trubisky CHI
23 Blake Bortles JAC
24 Jameis Winston TB
25 Andy Dalton CIN


You can follow, ask fantasy questions and yell at Brian on Twitter: @Spokes_Murphy

Never miss ASL’s latest fantasy sports news. Send us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and list the sports you are interested in (NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, EPL) to start receiving ASL’s newsletter.